UNIT TWO
The Immigrant Experience
of Chin Bark See

Unit 2 is the story of one immigrant's arduous attempt to legally enter the United States in the 1920's: his many interviews with the immigration service; and the myriad letters and documents involved.

ACTIVITY 1

The Chin Bark See Files

ACTIVITY 2

Making a Family Tree

ACTIVITY 3

Chin Bark See's Life

ACTIVITY 4

Comparing Immigrant Experiences

ACTIVITY 5

Writing a Play About Immigration



TIME FRAME:

One week.

PRODUCTS AND ASSESSMENT:

1. Family tree for Chin Bark See.  Students' own family trees.

2. Dramatic presentation: the immigration interview of Chin Bark See and students' own role-playing dialogs.


Background Information

Chin Bark See applied for permission to immigrate to the United States in 1922. He was the son of an American citizen, Chin Dean Bate, who was born in the United States. (See the Affidavit, dated October 24, 1921.)

In her 1992 book, Chinatown, Gwen Kinkead gives some background on the procedures that immigrants experienced at the time:

Many residents were "paper sons," illegal aliens with false identification papers. Any child born to an American citizen was automatically also a citizen, even if the child was born in China.  Laborers who had entered the country before the Exclusion Act and had obtained citizenship, or merchants who were exempted from the act, invariably told the U.S. Immigration Bureau when they returned from visits to China that they'd fathered sons there, whether they had or not. That opened up a slot for another Chinese, often a nephew or cousin, or perhaps a stranger from another district, to pose as the son.

Immigration grilled Chinese entering the U.S.--with so many originating near Canton, it became expert in Cantonese village life and family genealogies. "How many steps from the peach tree in back of your house to the village shrine?" inspectors asked. "How many sons did your mother's aunt have?" Paper sons studied these typical questions in their "coaching books," bought with their fake birth certificates, and had ready answers.  Hundreds managed to fool Immigration and take up residence under false names this way.


DOCUMENT 3

CHINESE EXCLUSION ACT CASE FILES: CHIN BARK SEE

Affidavit of Chin Dean Bate, 1921
Photographs: Chin Dean Bate and Chin Bark See
Testimony of Chin Bark See, 1922 Identification Papers, US Department of Labor
Application for Return Privilege, 1926
Second Testimony, 1926
Letter of Approval
Records in the Regional Archives of the National Archives and Records Administration

TRANSCRIPTION

TRANSCRIPTION OF THE TESTIMONY IN DOCUMENT 3

WORKSHEET 1

UNDERSTANDING CHIN BARK SEE'S FILE

WORKSHEET 2

INTERVIEW QUESTIONS


Activity 1